Review of Strobist DVD "Lighting in Layers"...

This is one of those reviews that is difficult for me to write, because I want to make sure you understand what an outstanding piece of work this is, but am fearful it will simply come across as a big David Hobby butt kissing love fest.

There is a lot to like about "Lighting in Layers", starting with the price, it's only $159 for a hard copy or $99 for the download.

Yes the price is low, but the value and quality of the content is high, very high. You will be getting 7 discs full of 9 hours of non-stop learning, no wasted time, no fluff, no filler (6 DVD's are "Lighting in layers", the 7th disc is the complete seminar in a lower res format that can be loaded on a portable media player). Though you are getting hours and hours of video the segments are relatively short, ranging from just 5-20 minutes long, so you attack it in small, manageable, easy to digest bites.

The DVD starts out teaching us the basics, shooting with just Window Light:

Then shows us how to shoot with a single flash (key light) and a window (fill light):

Then shooting with a flash only:

And from here is where it really takes off, with David showing us how to "Light in Layers", how to properly use of the building blocks of light, where to add light, in what order to add them, in shooting scenarios that become more challenging, more demanding.

He does it with a combination of easily accessible (and inexpensive) gear and many DIY alternatives (like aluminum foil reflectors, spaghetti box snoots, and Home Depot clamps). In fact you can see the complete list of gear used for each of the shoots.

Not only is "Lighting in Layers" affordable, it will teach you how to light affordably as well, all while giving your client the best possible product.

It is NOT meant to be a cookie cutter lighting recipe, it is meant to teach us how light(s) impact our subject.

There are six full shoots in total, all start at the very beginning - understanding the location, what the end result needs to be and how it will be lit. It then proceeds to actually setting up the equipment and then shoot and all that comes with it (the adjustments, changes, etc.). Five the the shoots are "on the road" assignments, and all are very different and provide a unique lighting/learning opportunities.

During each there are three different conversations going on, David is talking to (and teaching) us the viewer, he is talking to the model(s) (learning how to talk to/guide a person you are shooting is so important), and he is talking to his VALS (voice activated light stand, aka lighting assistant).

I really like the fact that as he presses the shutter the images appear immediately on the screen, even the clunkers, this makes it so much easier to follow the process and make the connection between what he is doing, the setup, and the image it produces.

Speaking of clunkers, there are times that David comes into a shoot with an idea, or tries something that doesn't work or needs to be changed and we get to see it (and he shares it) all, because that's what happens in real life and it's an important to learn how to adapt.

Each session wraps up with the "Lighting Notebook", David lays out a blank piece of paper and steps us through the lighting diagram, reinforcing what we just learned, which I found valuable.

And no opportunity is lost when it comes to teaching, there are a handful of studio shot "mini lectures" where Mr. Hobby challenges the viewers to figure out how it is lit, so we are learning from what he is saying, and learning to recognize how a scene is lit. "Deconstructing" is a pretty good learning tool. At the end of the lecture the camera zooms out, the lighting is revealed (and explained).

I was pleasantly surprised about the inclusion of the business aspect of photography (just wasn't expecting it), David has started a new local blog called HOCO360, a visual journal for Howard County Maryland, and he walks us through the decisions he made when setting it up, selecting assignments, client relations, and much more. So if you are looking to start your site, or improve the one you already have there are some real gems to learn from here too.

I also learned David is a funny guy, has a phenomenal sense of family, of community, and makes decisions based on "doing what is right". The kind of person you would want to have lunch with.

Well, his butt should be sufficiently wrinkled from all my kissing... but seriously, if you ever struggle with lighting, or simply don't shoot certain things because of a lack of confidence or know-how please invest in yourself, invest in your photography by purchasing (and watching) "Lighting in Layers", you will learn much from it, I did.


Miguel Palaviccini said...

Aha! I've been waiting for this. I can't wait to read and digest it tonight! Thanks again for reviewing this! I have his first set of DVD's and I love them!

Rick said...

I got this DVD set....Its really great for the lighting ideas....just wish he would share the camera settings...its sometimes hard to figure out what camera settings he is using...he makes camera setting adjustments quickly...based on his 'adding a little salt and pepper'....makes it sometimes hard to learns what our camera settings should be or atleast start out at...but, overall, outstanding teaching DVD's....definately recommend this!

Groupdmt said...

Really i appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge.The topic here i found was really effective to the topic which i was researching for a long time
colour correction

phtographer from usa said...

I would like to order one instead of enrolling to a photography class, I prefer this one since I just only wanna know the basics of shooting in window light.

digital photography expert said...

Very nice video. David has taught few tips related to photography in excellent way. Learn a lot and i will implement it while doing photography.